The Most Common Local SEO Mistakes (And How to Fix Them)

Written By Daniel Meek

Local SEO can make or break your business's online visibility. When done right, it puts your business in front of customers actively searching for your products or services in your area. But even small mistakes can cause your business to disappear from local search results, costing you valuable customers every single day.

After working with hundreds of local businesses, we've seen the same critical errors repeated time and again. The good news? Most of these mistakes are surprisingly easy to fix once you know what to look for.

1. Inconsistent NAP Information Across the Web

One of the most damaging mistakes is having inconsistent Name, Address, and Phone number (NAP) information across different online platforms. When Google crawls the web and finds conflicting information about your business, it loses confidence in which details are correct.

Common inconsistencies include:

  • Using "Street" on one listing and "St." on another

  • Different phone numbers on your website versus Google Business Profile

  • Suite numbers included on some listings but not others

  • Listing a PO Box instead of your physical location

The fix: Conduct a thorough audit of your business information across all platforms including your Google Business Profile, Bing Places, Apple Maps, Yelp, Facebook, and industry-specific directories. Create a master document with your exact NAP details and ensure every listing matches perfectly.

2. Neglecting Google Business Profile Optimization

Your Google Business Profile (formerly Google My Business) is the cornerstone of local SEO, yet many businesses either claim their listing and forget about it or fail to optimize it properly.

Critical elements often overlooked:

  • Incomplete business categories (both primary and secondary)

  • Missing business hours or special holiday hours

  • No business description utilizing local keywords

  • Sparse or outdated photos

  • Ignoring or slowly responding to customer reviews

  • Not utilizing Google Posts for updates and offers

The fix: Treat your Google Business Profile as a living, breathing marketing channel. Update it regularly with fresh photos, respond to every review within 24-48 hours, post weekly updates, and ensure every field is completely filled out with accurate, keyword-rich information.

3. Ignoring Online Reviews (or Handling Them Poorly)

Reviews are a critical ranking factor for local SEO, influencing both search visibility and customer decision-making. Some businesses make the mistake of not actively soliciting reviews, while others respond defensively to negative feedback.

Review mistakes to avoid:

  • Not having a system to request reviews from satisfied customers

  • Responding emotionally to negative reviews

  • Ignoring reviews entirely

  • Offering incentives in exchange for positive reviews (against most platform guidelines)

  • Having no reviews at all (raises red flags for potential customers)

The fix: Create a consistent review generation strategy. After successful transactions, send follow-up emails requesting reviews. When you receive negative reviews, respond professionally and offer to resolve issues offline. Thank customers for positive reviews. Remember that your responses are public and demonstrate your customer service quality to future customers.

4. Missing or Poor Local Content on Your Website

Many local businesses have websites that could be located anywhere. They fail to create content that signals relevance to their specific geographic area.

Content mistakes include:

  • No mention of your city, neighborhood, or service area

  • Generic content that doesn't address local customer needs

  • Missing location pages for businesses serving multiple areas

  • No locally-focused blog posts or resources

The fix: Incorporate your location naturally throughout your website—in title tags, meta descriptions, headers, and body content. Create dedicated service area pages for each location you serve. Write blog posts about local events, news, or topics relevant to your community. Include local landmarks and neighborhood names where appropriate.

5. Neglecting Local Link Building

While many businesses understand the importance of backlinks for SEO, they often overlook the particular value of local links from other businesses, organizations, and publications in their area.

Missed opportunities:

  • Not joining the local chamber of commerce or business associations

  • Failing to get listed in local business directories

  • Missing partnerships with complementary local businesses

  • No engagement with local news outlets or bloggers

  • Not sponsoring local events or charities (which often include website mentions)

The fix: Actively pursue relationships within your local business community. Sponsor Little League teams, participate in community events, collaborate with neighboring businesses, and pitch stories to local media. These activities often result in valuable local backlinks while strengthening your community presence.

6. Not Optimizing for "Near Me" and Mobile Searches

With over 60% of local searches happening on mobile devices, failing to optimize for mobile users is a critical mistake. "Near me" searches have exploded in recent years, and many businesses aren't positioned to capture this traffic.

Mobile optimization failures:

  • Slow-loading mobile website

  • Difficult-to-read text or buttons too small to tap

  • No click-to-call functionality

  • Forms that are frustrating to complete on mobile

  • Missing location-based keywords that trigger "near me" results

The fix: Ensure your website is fully responsive and loads quickly on mobile devices. Use Google's Mobile-Friendly Test tool to identify issues. Include your location in title tags and content to appear in "near me" searches. Make your phone number prominent and clickable on mobile devices.

7. Choosing the Wrong Business Categories

Your business category selection in directory listings, especially Google Business Profile, is crucial for appearing in relevant searches. Many businesses select incorrect categories or fail to add secondary categories.

Category mistakes:

  • Choosing a category that's too broad or generic

  • Selecting categories based on what you want to rank for rather than what you actually are

  • Not utilizing all available secondary category slots

  • Changing categories too frequently

The fix: Research which categories your successful competitors use. Choose the most specific primary category that accurately describes your business. Add secondary categories for additional services you offer. Be honest—Google can penalize businesses that misrepresent their category.

8. Duplicate Listings and Unclaimed Profiles

Duplicate listings confuse search engines and dilute your local SEO efforts. Similarly, unclaimed profiles on various platforms represent missed opportunities and can contain incorrect information.

Common issues:

  • Multiple Google Business Profiles for the same location

  • Old listings from previous addresses or phone numbers

  • Listings created by customers or third parties that you never claimed

  • Franchise or multi-location businesses with overlapping listings

The fix: Search for your business name across all major platforms to identify duplicate or unclaimed listings. Claim what you can and request deletion of true duplicates. For listings you can't access, use the platform's support to report issues or request ownership.

9. Overlooking Schema Markup

Local business schema markup is code added to your website that helps search engines understand your business information better. Many local businesses either don't implement schema at all or implement it incorrectly.

What to include in local business schema:

  • Business name, address, and phone number

  • Business hours

  • Geographic coordinates

  • Price range

  • Accepted payment methods

  • Service area

The fix: Implement LocalBusiness schema markup on your website. Use Google's Structured Data Testing Tool to ensure it's correctly formatted. If you're not comfortable with code, consider hiring a developer or using a WordPress plugin that automates this process.

10. Not Tracking Local SEO Performance

You can't improve what you don't measure. Many businesses invest in local SEO without establishing metrics to track success, making it impossible to know what's working and what needs adjustment.

Metrics to monitor:

  • Google Business Profile insights (views, clicks, calls, direction requests)

  • Local keyword rankings

  • Organic traffic from local searches

  • Conversion rates from local visitors

  • Phone calls and form submissions from organic search

  • Review quantity and average rating over time

The fix: Set up Google Analytics and Google Search Console if you haven't already. Regularly check your Google Business Profile insights. Use local rank tracking tools to monitor your visibility for important local keywords. Create monthly reports to identify trends and opportunities.

Take Action Today

Local SEO mistakes can cost you customers, revenue, and growth opportunities. The good news is that most of these issues are entirely fixable with focused effort and attention to detail.

Start by auditing your current local SEO presence against this checklist. Prioritize fixing the most critical issues first—particularly your Google Business Profile optimization and NAP consistency. Then work through the remaining items systematically.

Remember, local SEO is not a one-time project but an ongoing commitment. Regular maintenance, consistent optimization, and staying current with best practices will keep you ahead of your competition in local search results.

Need help fixing your local SEO mistakes? Contact Main Street SEO today for a comprehensive local SEO audit and customized strategy to dominate local search in your area.

Daniel Meek
Previous

The Ultimate Direct-to-Consumer Brand Launch Checklist